@ghstahl I think we had a similar conversation on Slack 🙂

For future readers, if you want to be able to distinguish how a user logs in (which idp they use), this might be helpful:

If I were you, I'd look at two things:

the user login success event: https://fusionauth.io/docs/extend/events-and-webhooks/events/user-login-success which has the identityProviderId It is provided as an event, so I don't know if it'll work for you, but it will tell you on every login event which idp was used. You could possibly store that off someplace and build a system to exchange an id token for the idp used. I'd have to think more about how that works, but it might be possible. setting up in your own app a 'sign me in' button and not using an idp hint. You'd instead build the authorization URL for each idp and build a link for entry into each navigation area. https://fusionauth.io/docs/apis/identity-providers/openid-connect#complete-an-openid-connect-login You'd let the user login and then come back. The redirect URL could be different and that would be the distinguishing feature.
If a user started at /googlestart, clicked the 'sign me in' button, and arrived back at /googleendpage and had a valid token, the user went through the google process.
If a user started at /secretidp1start, clicked the 'sign me in' button and ended up back at the /secretidp1endpage with a valid token, then the user went through the secret idp 1 process.